Orion Shield vs RaidProtect
RaidProtect and Orion Shield are two Discord security bots born in France. RaidProtect focuses on anti-raid and anti-spam; Orion Shield adds anti-nuke, scam image detection and AI moderation.
In short
- You want a raid mode adjustable up to 24 hours with several reactions (blocking invites, captcha, kicking in Premium).
- You need a bot translated into many languages.
- You also want an anti-nuke against hacked accounts and rogue moderators.
- You want to remove scam images and moderate toxicity and NSFW with AI.
- You want to kick newcomers during a raid without Premium.
Feature by feature
| Feature | Orion Shield | RaidProtect |
|---|---|---|
| Anti-nuke: channels and roles | Yes | Not documented |
| Anti-nuke: bans and kicks in a row (anti mass actions) | Yes | Not documented |
| Webhook protection | YesWebhook spam blocked by the anti-spam. | Not documented |
| Server name and icon protected | Yes | Not documented |
| Quarantine of a suspect member | PartialRemoval of sensitive roles. | Not documented |
| Server backup and restore | No | Not documented |
| Automatic raid mode | Yes | YesUp to 24 hours; kicking newcomers is in Premium. |
| Captcha | Yes | Yes |
| Minimum account age | Yes | Not documented |
| Anti-bot | Yes | Not documented |
| Anti-spam | Yes | Yes |
| Scam images (text read and fingerprints) | Yes | Not documented |
| Link and invite filters | Yes | Not documented |
| AI toxicity moderation | YesLegendary plan, free by voting. | Not documented |
| NSFW image detection | Yes | Not documented |
| Logs | Yes | Not documented |
| Bot in French | Yes | Yes |
| Price | Free. The Legendary plan is free by voting. | Free, Premium at $2.99 a month (Founder offer). |
“Not documented” means the public documentation doesn't mention it, not that the feature doesn't exist. The details of each Orion Shield protection, with its thresholds and limits: features documentation
What RaidProtect does well
- Automatic or manual raid mode, up to 24 hours.
- An adaptive anti-spam with ten different triggers.
- A trap channel (HoneyPot) and closing private messages during a raid.
Use both?
Two anti-raid bots on the same server step on each other: pick a single one for raid mode and the captcha.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between RaidProtect and Orion Shield?
Both protect against raids and spam. Orion Shield adds channel and role anti-nuke, protection of the server name and icon, scam image detection and AI moderation, all for free.
Sources
- RaidProtect : anti-raid
- RaidProtect : captcha
- RaidProtect : anti-spam
- RaidProtect : Premium
- Orion Shield: code of version 2.5, summed up in the features documentation