Orion Shield vs Carl-bot
Carl-bot is known for its reaction roles, logs and automod. Orion Shield specializes in protection against raids, hacked accounts, spam and scams.
In short
- You want reaction roles, automatic messages and detailed logs.
- You want an automatic raid mode, a captcha, a minimum account age and an anti-nuke.
- You want to remove scam images and moderate with AI.
Feature by feature
| Feature | Orion Shield | Carl-bot |
|---|---|---|
| Anti-nuke: channels and roles | Yes | Not documented |
| Anti-nuke: bans and kicks in a row (anti mass actions) | Yes | Not documented |
| Webhook protection | YesWebhook spam blocked by the anti-spam. | Not documented |
| Server name and icon protected | Yes | Not documented |
| Quarantine of a suspect member | PartialRemoval of sensitive roles. | Not documented |
| Server backup and restore | No | Not documented |
| Automatic raid mode | Yes | Not documented |
| Captcha | Yes | Not documented |
| Minimum account age | Yes | Not documented |
| Anti-bot | Yes | Not documented |
| Anti-spam | Yes | Not documented |
| Scam images (text read and fingerprints) | Yes | Not documented |
| Link and invite filters | Yes | Yes |
| AI toxicity moderation | YesLegendary plan, free by voting. | Not documented |
| NSFW image detection | Yes | Not documented |
| Logs | Yes | Yes |
| Bot in French | Yes | Not documented |
| Price | Free. The Legendary plan is free by voting. | Free, with a paid Premium. |
“Not documented” means the public documentation doesn't mention it, not that the feature doesn't exist. The details of each Orion Shield protection, with its thresholds and limits: features documentation
What Carl-bot does well
- Very complete reaction roles and automations.
- Detailed automod and logs.
Use both?
Carl-bot for roles and organization, Orion Shield for protection: they complement each other without getting in the way.
Frequently asked questions
Does Carl-bot have an anti-raid?
Its documentation describes an automod and logs, without a dedicated anti-raid or anti-nuke module. Orion Shield brings these protections.
Sources
- Carl-bot : documentation de l’automod
- Orion Shield: code of version 2.5, summed up in the features documentation