---
title: "Orion Shield vs Carl-bot: which bot to protect your Discord server? · Orion Shield"
description: "Orion Shield or Carl-bot? A factual comparison: roles, automod, logs, anti-raid, anti-nuke, scam images and AI moderation."
url: https://orion-shield.com/en/docs/comparisons/orion-shield-vs-carl-bot
language: en
alternates:
  fr: https://orion-shield.com/docs/comparaisons/orion-shield-vs-carl-bot
---

Comparison

# Orion Shield vs Carl-bot

Carl-bot is known for its reaction roles, logs and automod. Orion Shield specializes in protection against raids, hacked accounts, spam and scams.

Checked on October 25, 2026. Orion Shield's column comes from its code, Carl-bot's from its public documentation. Spotted a mistake? Report it on the support server.

## In short

**Choose Carl-bot if…**

- You want reaction roles, automatic messages and detailed logs.

**Choose Orion Shield if…**

- You want an automatic raid mode, a captcha, a minimum account age and an anti-nuke.
- You want to remove scam images and moderate with AI.

## Feature by feature

| Feature | Orion Shield | Carl-bot |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Anti-nuke: channels and roles | Yes | Not documented |
| Anti-nuke: bans and kicks in a row (anti mass actions) | Yes | Not documented |
| Webhook protection | Yes · Webhook spam blocked by the anti-spam. | Not documented |
| Server name and icon protected | Yes | Not documented |
| Quarantine of a suspect member | Partial · Removal of sensitive roles. | Not documented |
| Server backup and restore | No | Not documented |
| Automatic raid mode | Yes | Not documented |
| Captcha | Yes | Not documented |
| Minimum account age | Yes | Not documented |
| Anti-bot | Yes | Not documented |
| Anti-spam | Yes | Not documented |
| Scam images (text read and fingerprints) | Yes | Not documented |
| Link and invite filters | Yes | Yes |
| AI toxicity moderation | Yes · Legendary plan, free by voting. | Not documented |
| NSFW image detection | Yes | Not documented |
| Logs | Yes | Yes |
| Bot in French | Yes | Not documented |
| Price | Free. The Legendary plan is free by voting. | Free, with a paid Premium. |

“Not documented” means the public documentation doesn't mention it, not that the feature doesn't exist. The details of each Orion Shield protection, with its thresholds and limits: [features documentation](https://orion-shield.com/en/docs/features)

## What Carl-bot does well

- Very complete reaction roles and automations.
- Detailed automod and logs.

## Use both?

Carl-bot for roles and organization, Orion Shield for protection: they complement each other without getting in the way.

## Frequently asked questions

Does Carl-bot have an anti-raid?

Its documentation describes an automod and logs, without a dedicated anti-raid or anti-nuke module. Orion Shield brings these protections.

## Sources

- [Carl-bot : documentation de l’automod](https://github.com/botlabs-gg/carlbot-docs/blob/master/docs/automod.md)
- Orion Shield: code of version 2.5, summed up in the [features documentation](https://orion-shield.com/en/docs/features)

## Other comparisons

[**Orion Shield vs Wick** A factual comparison of Orion Shield and Wick: anti-nuke, anti-raid, captcha, anti-spam, scam images, AI moderation, backups and price, with sources.](https://orion-shield.com/en/docs/comparisons/orion-shield-vs-wick) [**Orion Shield vs DraftBot** Orion Shield or DraftBot? A factual comparison of two French Discord bots: anti-raid, anti-nuke, captcha, anti-spam, scams, AI moderation and price.](https://orion-shield.com/en/docs/comparisons/orion-shield-vs-draftbot) [**Orion Shield vs RaidProtect** Orion Shield or RaidProtect? A factual comparison of two French Discord security bots: raid mode, captcha, anti-spam, anti-nuke, scams and price.](https://orion-shield.com/en/docs/comparisons/orion-shield-vs-raidprotect) [**Orion Shield vs Beemo** Orion Shield or Beemo? A factual comparison: raid detection, anti-nuke, captcha, anti-spam, scams, AI moderation and price.](https://orion-shield.com/en/docs/comparisons/orion-shield-vs-beemo) [**Orion Shield vs Dyno** Orion Shield or Dyno? A factual comparison: automod, anti-spam, anti-raid, anti-nuke, scam images, AI moderation and price.](https://orion-shield.com/en/docs/comparisons/orion-shield-vs-dyno)

## Protect your server with Orion

Anti-raid, anti-nuke, anti-scam and AI moderation: add Orion to your Discord server and set everything up with /settings.

[Add bot](https://orion-shield.com/invite) [Discord Server →](https://discord.gg/BC3rE6f7GB)
